Jay's Seafood Grill - Yorkville

I have tried to give this restaurant several chances to get my food correct. After not ordering from them for a year, I ordered today and spent over $50 and was totally disappointed in the food. I ordered 12 pieces Jack Salmon and received these little nuggets that I did not know until I reached home. My chicken was not cooked hard enough. When I called the worker stated that he would refund me for my order. After five minutes, he called back and said the manager was going to call me to redo my Jack Salmon order as they gave me the wrong item, little nuggets. The manager never called and I wasted over $50. I have definitely learned my lesson with this place and will never patronize again. This restaurant has gotten worse, if that is even possible.

Had a Gyro sandwich and meat was dry but the pita was grilled (nice touch). Tziki sauce was good.Also ordered grilled catfish. It was definitely grilled but needed for flavoring. Will try the fried version next time. Fries were crispy and on point.

Purchased chicken wings and catfish from here today and not only were the wings very tiny, they were black (old) and had a funky smell when I separated the wing and smelled it. The catfish had a weird smell as well. I stopped eating both bc neither smelled or tasted fresh I started to feel a bit nauseous from the smell. You also have to buy fries and bread separately, for the price that should come with the meal. Needless to say, I wanted to call get our money back, however, we will just take the loss not go back again. Sorry, I do not recommend.... would never have taken a risk selling a customer bad food.

I was the last customer at at this restaurant and would have rather they told me they were closed or not cooking anymore for the night. I asked to have the chicken fried hard not reheated in old grease. I have had the chicken before and it was amazing. This was plain disgusting .the fries were even over cooked I guess on the old grease also) I called to let them know and was told they could do nothing. I would have preferred a new order or my money back they can have this disgusting food back it was not eaten. I drove 20 minutes to be given garbage. I am very disappointed and would not recommend them to anyone!

Stopped in specifically to try the cat fish. They did not disappoint. Staff was very friendly. My son had the 3 piece chicken dinner. It was good. Bit be sure to try the catfish!!!