Margarita's Cafe - Williston Park

I wanted to eat with my cousin on 3/12/2022. Fatima our server was excellent. I think she deserves a resurrection because I testify to her beards, greetings and sitting guests. And answer the phones. The food was very good.

Been there twice very nice a little tight and crowded but that's okay people have to get out.. had the lobster tail paella. It was fine a little oily....but.my lobster was excellent.. I had two mojitos and they were excellent. . Definitely go back again. And the homemade guacamole that they make in front of you is ..five stars

We had a fantastic time at this trendy restaurant. The menu offered an excellent variety of unique dishes alongside all the classic favorites. The margaritas were delicious too! I wish I had been hungrier because I would have loved to order more. The waitstaff were incredibly friendly, and the overall cleanliness of the place was impressive. While the partitions between tables seem to be a necessity nowadays, the paper tablecloths added a nice touch and felt classy. I would definitely give this restaurant a 10/10 and highly recommend it!

I absolutely love this restaurant! The mariachi music, the Frida Kahlo-inspired decor, and the friendly atmosphere make it a wonderful spot. You have to try the passion fruit margaritas – they're a highlight! The staff is consistently friendly, and even when the place is busy, the service remains excellent. My go-to dish here is the “pollo aguacate.” Since the restaurant is quite small, it's best for small groups. I highly recommend making a reservation, as it gets crowded, and waiting can take a while.

Our server was an absolute gem—sweet and attentive. However, the noise level in the restaurant was overwhelming. We found ourselves shouting across the table, and even a slight reduction in the music volume would have made it more bearable. The Mariachi band was entertaining, but combined with the loud music, it reached around 110 decibels. I do think the staff should consider their hearing! As for the food, it was just okay—not particularly memorable. The tostones were hard as rocks, the shrimp tacos were dry and overcooked, and the chicken fajitas were bland. Unfortunately, I ended up eating the sides that accompanied my husband's meal and barely touched my tacos after a single bite. On the bright side, the drinks were fantastic! They serve some excellent margaritas. I tried Willy's Panchos margarita, and it was strong yet delicious. If you're looking for great-tasting and affordable cocktails, this is definitely the place to go. However, I wouldn't recommend it for the food. I've heard that other nearby restaurants are more spacious, so I might check those out next time.