Gelateria Dei Coltelli - Williston Park

Extremely lively popular place. Good flavors. I wish all the flavors were marked.

A nifty little shop with big options. I had the gelato cookie sandwich and, for six bucks, it was absolutely fantastic. More importantly, it didn’t taste old and didn’t feel like concrete. I don’t live in the neighborhood and would absolutely put some miles on my odometer just to go here. Moreover, the server was very attentive and made my visit feel welcomed. Next time I’m going to try their pistachio and strawberry flavors. Highly recommend!

My favorite gelato place in LI! I love how they have different flavors all the time. The staff is very helpful, too

We don't go here often because the line tends to be rather long and sometimes even wraps around the block. When we do visit, I always have such a fun time looking at all their flavor options and trying one or two before deciding what to get. My most recent favorite is their bacio, which is such a great mix of hazelnuts and chocolate. I've also really enjoyed their peanut butter and banana nutella flavors in the past. I love how they give you a tiny ice cream cone to go with your gelato. So cute! I really want to try their crepes one day maybe when it isn't so packed and the wait won't take forever. Can't wait to return again soon!

In my experience, this place offers the creamiest gelato I've ever had. I tried the pistachio and mango flavors together, and the combination was amazing. I will definitely be returning!