New York Pizzeria - Walnut

I can't believe it took over 30 minutes to get a single pizza! It's frustrating enough that you use canned ingredients, but not informing customers about potential wait times is inexcusable. And don’t even get me started on the terrible customer service. You chose this job, so please show a little professionalism. If you’re part owner, the others should be embarrassed. This was my first and last visit (April 8, 2024). I WILL NOT BE BACK. Save your money and go somewhere else.

This is the best pizza you can find! It’s as authentic as New York/New Jersey pizza can get. Highly recommended! I think adding chicken parmesan and eggplant parmesan sandwiches to the menu would be fantastic.

The staff could be more welcoming and should smile more often; they often seem quite unhappy. However, the food is absolutely delicious!

Tried a pizza and sandwich. It was good. Other competitors in the area, so there was plenty of seating available in the dining room when I dropped by to pick up my order.

Bought a BBQ beef sandwich to go. Sooooo disappointed! Ive been buying food from here over 25 years and this is the first time ive been disappointed in their BBQ beef sandwich! Definitely NOT the same! Bread is like a small thin breakfast roll and they left out the provolone cheese. Yet still charged me $10. WTHNOT okay and NOT happy ?