John Anthony's Of Valley Stream

Wait an hour and a half for two sandwiches. Grilled chicken on pack was burned and not edible. Very small egg on pepper and egg hero. Probably she won't use what's sad because we're trying to support locals.

The owner changed the salad menu. Gorgonzola salad with grilled chicken that are used to cranberries and walnuts, a good amount of salad green and gorgonzola. Walked on no cranberries and no walnuts, barely salad green, less chicken and gorgonzola and tomato slices with the core. All this cut back and price increase! It won't go back!

They were able to make a really good no cheese pizza for me.

Really consistent quality. The Greek salad is pretty awesome. The only complaint is when we get toppings on half the pizza, the cutting is pretty uneven and my husband seems to always get much bigger slices, which is sad for me because the pizza is pretty darned good!

The owners and staff are super friendly. They have, by far, the best pizza around.