Gencarelli's - Toms River

Don't be deceived by the quaint little cottage; they serve the best pizza we've ever tasted. It's worth the trip! The sauce is perfectly balanced—never burnt or overly sour like some other pizzas. The cheese is top-quality and not at all greasy, while the crust has the delightful taste of fresh Italian bread. Once you try their pizza, you'll find yourself hooked. There's truly nothing like it anywhere else. To top it all off, the staff is incredibly friendly. Five stars just don't do it justice!

They have lovely outdoor tables that are perfect for summer, but they can be quite chilly in winter, even though there is a fire pit outside. The restaurant is open year-round, but during the winter months, the outdoor seating is almost the only option, as there are no indoor seats available. They do offer free delivery within a 5-mile radius. I haven't tried two dinners yet, but the pizza I had was excellent!

We visited this place after a football match, and I must admit, I wouldn't have thought to check out Kettle Creek otherwise, but now I have a reason to come down this street. The pizza was delightful—thin crust and not greasy at all. The meatball parm we ordered was the best I've ever had. Plus, it's located outside by the water, which adds to the experience. (It's BYOB!) I can easily picture gathering some friends or family with a few bottles of wine for a lovely evening. Definitely worth a visit!

Today my first order was as I heard from other people. I am a white cake lover, so I had to give him an attempt, it was really the best I had in the area!!!! I would recommend this place for your next pizza order!!! I am now a loyal customer!!!!

Everything we have gotten from Gencarelli's has been excellent the pizza's, the appetizer's, the dinner entree's !!!!! And besides the food the whole staff is AMAZING they treat you like FAMILY, Gencarelli's is the best thing to happen to our little community in silverton !!!!!