Attilio's Pizza - Toms River

I ordered a gluten-free pepperoni pizza, a gluten-free white pizza, and gluten-free mozzarella sticks for about $55 (including taxes, tips, and two drinks). Overall, I was satisfied with everything, and there were no issues with cross-contamination. I just wish there had been more sauce on the pizza because it was so delicious. It might have been a gluten-free crust issue since they tend to absorb a lot of sauce. The crust itself was nothing special, but it got the job done. The mozzarella sticks were fantastic; I haven't had them in a decade. I would definitely eat here again.

After having a completely screwed up experience via doordash with Attilio's we proceeded to order straight through them and pick up. While picking up my order, I inquired if they delivered to my address, to which I was told yes and to bypass doordash entirely... Attilo's has the best pizza we have found in our area since moving here a few years ago. They are very accommodating and make any attempt to work with you. The customer service is fantastic, the owner is very nice and handles any issues immediately. I can't recommend them enough.

I've been meaning to write a review for a while now. We usually order from Attilio about once a week, and it's by far the best place we've tried in Toms River. We've had everything from takeout to subs and catering, and everything has been great. The only downside I’d mention is that delivery times can sometimes be a bit unpredictable, but I understand they get a lot of orders. We typically order online, which gives us an estimated wait time, so we know what to expect before placing our order. In short, you can order from here with complete confidence.

I am writing this review about my catering order that we all enjoyed on Sunday, December 26. I ordered the 5-tablet package for $199, which serves 10 to 12 people. I chose penne with vodka sauce, chicken Murphy, sausage and peppers, roasted potatoes, and an antipasto salad. They also included a bag of fresh bread. Everything was absolutely delicious, and the portions were more than enough for our family of 10. We couldn’t get enough of the food; each dish was incredibly tasty! I would definitely order from Attilio in Toms River again. The ordering process was very straightforward, and the food was ready exactly when I requested it. Great job, Attilios! You've gained a customer for life!

Very good food! The chicken stall with vodka sauce is delicious. Bread for Subs is the best I had! The staff is friendly and the delivery time is accurate. I usually order once a week and grab a piece of 2-3 days a week. The chicken parm pizza and meatball pizza is my way to order through the slice.