Peace Pie - St. Augustine

We had a good ice cream sandwich here. It was expensive. If it was layered with pie filling, it sure didn't look like it...but it was good on a hot day. Had to eat it outside because someone was smoking pot in the back and the store reeeked of it.

The ice cream sandwiches were amazing! I got the peanut butter cookie dough. My husband got the peaches and cream.....the size of those sandwiches were great for the price

Amazing flavors. Fresh ice cream with generous portion on crispy cookies. An absolute must in St Augustine !!

Very cute store and creative idea for a snack. The ice cream is tasty and they are quite creative with flavor pairings. The cookie is solid and holds the ice cream and pie filing well. I would call this a sharable treat since it’s so rich. It would also be fun to get two different sandwiches and share them so you can try two because it’s hard to choose just one.

One of the best treats ever. My family rarely eats sweets or desserts but this place is amazing. The main event: the best-ever ice cream stuffed between two delicious and somehow crispy cookies. So many flavors. I have had chocolate, fudge, caramel, coffee, a mixture of those, mint chocolate chip, cookie dough, lemon and key lime pie. Just keep going back to try them all. For those who cannot have ice cream, buy the cookies. Really buttery and delicious.