The Old Salty Dog Siesta Key

It’s time at Old Salty Dog. Food, and atmosphere was excellent. What we enjoyed was the service and our server. Her name is Genevieve, when she walked up to our table, she smiled and greeted us. She was attentive, professional, and courteous. What surprised us, we found out it is her first day as a server on her own. I definitely recommend the Old Salty Dog. We will be back. Parking: In front of building

Top 5 best fish n chips I’ve had. 1 large piece of cod, cooked perfectly, super moist and flavorful! Must try if you like fish n chips.Relaxed atmosphere, set outside and it was great

Everything about The Salty Dog in Siesta Key was excellent. They made us and BOTH of our large dogs (GSD and Lab) feel very welcome and comfortable. As a pet owner, this is the best restaurant we’ve been to! From the available clean water bowls to their own menu, my boys want to go back. Every Day.Oh, and our food was amazing!!!Thank you for making us all feel welcome!

The grouper in the fish and chips is as big as the basket of chips.... definetly a good choice. Although I didn't take a pic of it. It was gone before I thought about sharing. Lol ?

We had high expectations for this establishment, saving it for the final night of our trip. However, our experience began poorly when we requested indoor seating but were seated outside at a high-top table. Despite waiting about 20 minutes without a server, we only received attention after flagging down a table busser. Even then, it took another 10 minutes to finally get a server, who seemed rushed and didn't apologize for the delay. Despite the slow start, we decided to stay, hoping the food would compensate. I ordered the $25.99 coconut shrimp dinner with two sides: a side salad and rosemary potatoes. The salad arrived quickly, but most of the lettuce was red, wilted and tasted off. When the entrees arrived, my shrimp was burnt, and the potatoes were bland. My husband's loaded salty dog was okay, but his fries were cold.I typically don't leave reviews, but we were genuinely disappointed. Out of the five nights we dined in the village, this was the only establishment where we had a negative experience. We had much better meals for less than what I paid tonight. After hearing such great things, I hope this was just a rough night for them, but I felt the need to share.Pictured is the $26 Coconut Shrimp dinner with the potatoes, I didn’t think to take a picture of the salad.