Freshy Fresh Bagels - Shirley

June 2022 , WOW WHAT RIPOFF ALL PRICING ... and you the client buyers are the issue . Bagel STOPS HERE YES HAHA ..Wake up buyers as I have AND ANY OTHER LOCAL L I once normal pricing . Today , poppy bagel 1.50 wow W smear of butter 1.25 wow tax The rest of the wall foods were insane . You buyers are too blame , stop using this store 901 Montauk hgwy ,shirley Sams w high gas , stop doing longer trips ... WAKE UP YOU FOOL BUYERS , AS I HAVE AMD Walked out ...over to B/ king or Macd PLEASE owner do NOT come back w your high.costs . For baking daily Bagels in a oven paid for 10 years ago .

Very disappointed. Bagels were not fresh at all. Ordered them through an app. They were definitely stale. Ordered from this store several times before but will not order from them again.

I traveled from Florida to visit family and was on the hunt for some bagels to take home. I arrived at around 11:15 and the place wasn’t busy at all. My sister’s husband suggested we check it out since he works for her tree service. I was not disappointed! I can't wait for everyone to experience what real New York bagels taste like. We just can’t find good bagels in Florida due to the water quality. I was warmly welcomed, and the service was excellent. The prices were reasonable, and the cream cheese was perfect! I’ll definitely come back during my next visit!

Justin, a dedicated worker, consistently makes the best bagels. I highly recommend this place to everyone! It's a fantastic spot!

This is the best bagel shop on the island! The bagels are always fresh! I make it a point to visit every summer when I’m in town, and I can't resist their bagels. The all-onion bagel is my favorite—it's incredibly delicious. Their egg sandwiches are out of this world, and the coffee is always hot and fresh. The staff is consistently cheerful and eager to ensure your order is prepared exactly as you want it. I wouldn’t choose any other place!