Shelter Island Slice

When ever I drive through even if I’m not hungry I have to grab a I always grab a slice. Great pizza!

Look no further if you're in search of excellent pizza. Shelter Island Slice has been my favorite since I was a child, even surpassing the famed pizza in New Haven, Connecticut. The ever-changing menu and fantastic staff make this spot a standout. With good vibes and delicious pizza, what more could you ask for?

The pizza is fantastic at this restaurant, but it is always bustling with customers. I try to ignore the odd and aggressive behavior of the owner towards anyone placing an order or picking up their food. Despite his intimidating attitude, the pizza is worth it. However, he could definitely work on being more relaxed and customer-friendly.

The customer service at this restaurant is outstanding, I would give it 11 out of 10! I visit this place weekly and every experience has been positive. Everything I've tried here has been delicious. During my last visit, I was even given a sample of the amaretto tiramisu, which was fantastic (the regular tiramisu is amazing too). I highly recommend this restaurant, it's my favorite spot for food on the island.

Frankie still makes the best pizza in the area by far.