Yoder's Amish Village - Sarasota

If I could give this restaurant more stars, I definitely would! Our server, Johnathan, was not only knowledgeable but also incredibly friendly. The food was outstanding—clearly fresh and made from scratch. We tried the meatloaf dinner, fried chicken dinner, and country fried steak dinner, and all of them were fantastic. The side dishes of mashed potatoes, fries, and warm apples were equally delicious. The desserts were amazing as well; we enjoyed egg custard pie, strawberry cream pie, and key lime pie. The portions were generous too. I will absolutely return and highly recommend that you give this place a try!

The food here is delicious! I couldn't leave Sarasota without trying this place. I must admit that the meat and noodles had a bold flavor—maybe a bit too salty for my taste—but the consistency and texture were excellent. The service is quick and efficient. I will definitely return!

The line stretched out the door for this hidden gem, and once you step inside, you'll see why. The food is as close to home-cooked meals as you can get. Every dish that came out of the kitchen left us wanting to order even more. And let's not even get started on the pie—our banana pie was simply indescribable; it was a slice of heaven. This place is undoubtedly one of the top ten best restaurants in Sarasota, FL.

Yoder?s has some quality home-cooking in the heart of Sarasota in a small Amish Village. The service is friendly and attentive as expected. The portions are large and plentiful. Loved the gravy, but the meat was either very bland, or super salty. Still tender though. I?d recommend Yoder?s as a great alternative to the usual Italian/Mediterranean/Mexican/Seafood places that dominate the area.

This has always been one of my favorite Amish restaurants in town, so when I?m in the area it?s always a must to stop by here. One of my favorites on their menu is their chocolate cake and that?s what we stopped by to get. The regular menu is of course, great home style cooking and options. The added store near here is a must to stop into, lots of cute items and something for everyone!