El Viejo Almacén En Viejo San Juan

The food was fantastic, and the atmosphere was incredible. The dessert was among the best I've ever tasted.

Excellent Argentine cuisine in Old San Juan with a fantastic location. We ordered the Parrillada for two, which was an enormous amount of food and offered excellent value for the price. They also have an extensive wine selection. I would definitely come back the next time I'm in town!

The food was satisfactory, but definitely overpriced. The service was quite disappointing. They charged us $8.50 for water that we didn't even order. The hostess spent the entire time on the phone while seating us. We would have preferred to wait until she finished her call, but instead, she just gestured at us as she tried to show us to our table. To make matters worse, she started sweeping under our table while we were still eating—not that we lingered too long; our reservation was at 7:15. Additionally, our waitress forgot to place our dessert order, and we ended up waiting 45 minutes before we could ask her about it. She didn't even attempt to bring us the check during that entire time. Overall, dinner took over 2.5 hours. I would recommend looking for another place.

Great food! Make a reservation— this place is busy, but the best meal we had in San Juan. Service— including the hostess— was wonderful:

Amazing food and a wonderful place. Plan on 2.5 to 3 hours for the full experience. Will definitely be coming back next time we are in Puerto Rico.