Caruso's Pizzeria - Riverhead

Disappointed, always liked their pizza in the past but haven't been there in quite some time and this time I ordered 3 large pies to go, although they tasted fine one cheese pie was an obvious reheat.I always expect my pies to be fresh from the oven.

Best pizza around. Thin, crisp, amazing. This is my kids first stop when they come back into town.

I ordered calzone with ham. They gave me a side of sauce, Their sauce is delicious.I’ve tried a lot of places, there’s is the Best !!!!They were so friendly and quick. They’re my Italian Restaurant from here out. TY Parking: In the parking lot near CVS Riverhead, and Inga’s Cleaners.

Really nasty I got chicken cutlets for me and my family also chicken fingers/ fries for my kids it was not worth what I spent… the chicken was super chewy, it should’ve been cooked longer. ??? Disgusting and my kids chicken tenders and fries ? like how do you mess up that? I usually don’t write reviews but this needed a review!!! I was so mad about the amount of money spent on trash food

A life saver! We were tired after kayaking and HUNGRY on our way to our campsite. We googled several other places and was even on our way to another pizzeria when I read the reviews for Caruso’s. I felt confident about their pizza and boy was my hunch right! They did not disappoint, in fact they came all the way through with authentic NYC pizza. From the sauce to the cheese to the crust, this is a pizza you can trust! We ordered a pie and ate it with smiles on our faces.