Mr Pizza Slice - Red Bank

The food was fantastic! However, it’s disappointing that this historic landmark has undergone renovations. I even skipped school to visit and spotted Jon Bon Jovi there! I really hope the old booths and video games are preserved in a museum.

The cheese slice is fantastic! Everything about it is perfect—absolutely no flaws. A great slice for just $3!

I purchased two slices today and found them inedible. The texture was like chewing gum, the cheese was disappointing, and the crust was terrible. This is not the same Mr. Pizza slice I used to enjoy.

I’m originally from Jersey, and this pizza was great. The perfect crust, good cheese, the right amount of greasiness, sauce with the right balance and a slice for the right price under$2!

I had lunch at Mr Pizza Slice at least once a week when I worked in Red Bank from the mid-70s until I moved to FL in 1995. Even through illness Steve cooked the most perfect burgers I have ever had enhanced by the sautéed onions and peppers topping that had a secret ingredient. Steve finally told me what it is but made me promise that I never tell. I still haven't told anyone.