Wise Guys Pizzeria - Penn Yan

Excellent pizza. The sauce is excellent and taste like homemade Italian. This place will not disappoint!

I absolutely love their pizzas! The chicken wing pizza is my favorite. The service is consistently excellent, and the quality is always top-notch.

As a plumber in New York City, I love exploring different types of pizza. Based on the great reviews I came across, I decided to try Wise Guys Pizza, and I can't imagine looking for anything else now! This pizza truly stands out among NYC options. I usually stick to a classic plain pie, always with extra cheese. When I come back, that's where I'll be heading! I just don't have the time to sample everything out there!

Although I don't believe their pizza is the best out there (I make my own), their subs are amazing! I particularly enjoy the chicken finger sub with BBQ sauce and bleu cheese.