Mangino’s Pizzeria - New Castle

4.5 overall friendly service alot of variety of food choices very tasty .....atmosphere clean spacious always an option when in the area.

We really, really like your puzza. Especially the standard red sauce w/mushrooms pepperoni toppings AND the SPINACH FRESH TOMATOES. I ALWAYS ask my husband to ask them to go light on the garlic, but he NEVER remembers. It's not that i don't like lots of garlic; it's just that it does not like me. Marilyn Wagner Dietary restrictions: See above about using a little less garlic on the otherwise DELICIOUS Spinach Fresh Tomato w/ mozzarella cheese Pizza.

The pizza is great. We stopped for lunch and had couple of slices of Pizza I ordered the Vegetable pizza which has cauliflower. Loved it. I had also ordered a mozzarella cheese salad with their house vinegarete dressing. We enjoyed it so much that we went out of the way to come back the next day for pizza again The staff is super nice ? Vegetarian options: Pizza selection are cheese, vegetable and spinach. Great mozzarella cheese salad

One of the best pizzas in town, no one makes Mangino's pizza

Very surprised by how many people love this place, but goes to show a difference in preferences and expectations. The food here is pricy for what you get. We grabbed pizza slices because the wait time for a 16 inch pizza was 35 40 mins (1:00pm on a Thursday . We chose the pizza slices 1 sausage and pepperoni and 1 meatball and pepperoni and grabbed a small house salad. The slices were warmed in a large toaster oven. Very sweet: sweet sauce and sweet crust. Not as much cheese as I’d like, and all ingredients tasted like they had been frozen bought. The house salad was crisp, regular butter lettuce leaf, and the Italian dressing tasted like a mixture of thousand island and vinegar. Overall taste: simple, flat favors, heavy handed with the sugar and poor dressing. That assessment would have been a 2 star rating. However, both of us (husband and I felt sick to our stomachs a few hours later, but nothing water, sleep, and 24 hours couldn’t fix : Hence, 1 star.