Pizza Palace - Middletown

The best pizza in Middletown and tasty meatball grinders? That was my experience three months ago, but now I'm feeling disappointed. The interior has been remodeled, and honestly, I preferred the previous layout. The pizza and meatball parmesan are noticeably different. When I inquired about roasted paprika for my meatball parm, the staff seemed confused. They initially placed the paprika on the side, but when I picked up my order and reiterated that I wanted it mixed in, they sent it back to the kitchen to be adjusted. In the past, my experiences with Jimmy and Forty were fantastic, but ever since new owners took over—while using the same recipes—things have changed, and not for the better. I'm really saddened by this, and I've revised my rating down to two stars.

I'm on the hunt for a new pizza spot, and I have to say, I was really impressed with both the service and the taste of the pizza. The place is cozy and recently renovated. I’ll definitely be returning!

I just moved here from New York, and this place has become my favorite place to order lunch. You have a nice selection of products on the menu at reasonable prices and excellent quality. I also love the staff; they are great people. I highly recommend it!

Oh, my God! Just TRY! Recently they renovated the place and changed their menu, We went to try this place again and let me tell you this place has become THE ABSOLUTE BEST PIZZA PLACE IN TOWN. We were shocked how good the food was, from pizza to delicious meals. Chicken francaise was from the world. It's a cook. Keep killing it.

New menu is amazing. I?ve never had such amazing pizza and pasta in middle town before. I love the renovation and new menu they got. The waitress was very sweet. This is definitely my new favorite pizza place. We?ll definitely return.