Casey's General Store - Licking

I've been waiting over two hours on three pizza's. Hands down the worst experience ever!! Meal type: Dinner Price per person: $30–50

Tough crust Asked for square slice get 6 slices instead I keep hoping it will get better and it doesn't...shame on me for expecting better Meal type: Dinner Price per person: $10–20

They advertise one price, then charge you for another. Show the manager and am told all she can do would be take down the sign. Just keep lying to customers. I 'll not come here again. Update: A day, two at the most, after being notified of the response to this review by Casey 's (Owner) I sent them a message via the link that was posted. A week later and nothing. This location will lie to you in order to get an extra dime of your money, and there is no follow-through by Casey 's (Owner).

I ordered two speciality pizzas online. I added extras. Payment was done online. I go and pickup my order. I didn't look at the pizza till at home. The pizza were not cut as ordered nor did they have the extras I had ordered. Called Casey's. Got told they ran out of pepperoni. I had to ask for a refund for what I had ordered. I was told they would call back with info on how to get my refund. Not impressed. Pizza wasn't done in the middle either. Salem Casey's is much better. I guess my expectations were to high.

Opens at 5 is a joke. Was there at 6 and the door was locked with an employee standing behind the register stocking cigarettes. Never stopping here again for food when going fishing.