Per Tutti - Jamesburg

Service was excellent. From the moment they greet you they could not be more happy to see you and want to make sure you feel welcome. Food is delicious. Go. Try it. BYOB. You will be glad you did.

This is the first restaurant review I’ve ever written. We had a last-minute meeting for 11 people on Valentine’s Day and needed a place to eat quickly. Per Tutti exceeded our expectations with just one day’s notice. We had never dined there before, so we weren’t sure what to anticipate. Everything turned out better than we could have imagined. Despite the restaurant being busy, they had the perfect table ready for us when we arrived. The service was outstanding, and the food—starting from the garlic butter bread to the exquisite coffee—was excellent. We all enjoyed our entrées, and the entire dining experience showcased professional skill. They even allowed us to bring our own cake, which they served for us. As older diners who have eaten at hundreds of restaurants over the years, we found Per Tutti to be truly exceptional. I highly recommend it.

Per Tutti is undoubtedly overrated. Perhaps we visited on an off day, but based on the reviews, we found it to be quite different from expectations. The restaurant struggled with two key aspects: the taste of the food and the quality of service. The ambiance was decent, but that wasn't enough to salvage our experience. The bread basket arrived only after our appetizers, and it was burnt, requiring us to send it back. The service was virtually non-existent; the gentleman assigned to our table was not attentive and we had to ask other staff members for assistance. The food itself was bland and lacked the Italian herbs that one would expect. There are definitely better dining options available in the area.

The food is delicious, with generous portions, and it's BYOB. The Old School ambiance gives it a classic 50s vibe, and the service is excellent. I can't wait to return!

The food was good. The staff is very attentive.