Fresh Catch Cafe - Homer

I just had dinner here with my son, and we were extremely impressed. The halibut was incredible, and my son really enjoyed the halibut fish and chips. The atmosphere is lovely, and the view is fantastic. I highly recommend this place and will definitely return!

The service was friendly and attentive, and the atmosphere was nice, though it felt a bit crowded. Normally, the view would have been lovely given the location on the spit, but we were unable to appreciate it due to thick fog. So why only four stars? I might be being a bit critical, but the combination of high prices and smaller portions is what led to my decision. I understand that costs are rising everywhere, and that Homer has its own factors contributing to expensive dining. However, with the price of meals—like the $20 burger and fries and $26 for the fish and chips—the portion of fries was quite small. The fish portion was also not particularly large. Plus, for a $45 steak, it would have been nice to have more than just a few pieces of potatoes and vegetables (I think I could have counted the potatoes on one hand). Therefore, considering the high prices and the small portions for relatively inexpensive sides, I felt it warranted a four-star rating instead of five.

The halibut fish and chips were delicious, and our server, Nate, provided excellent service. The portion size was generous, and despite the fog when we visited, the view of the ocean and mountains was still impressive. The atmosphere was really cozy as well.

4.4/5 Wonderful experience. Delicious food. Great service. Welcoming atmosphere. Entrees are large portions with elegant presentation. My only criticism is the appetizers are small portions especially for the prices. For example, the baked oysters are $22 and the six you receive are very small. Also, the clam chowder is in a small bowl for $7. We will definitely return to enjoy this restaurant and recommend them to you.

I had the pleasure of visiting this place during the summer, and although it was incredibly busy with a long wait time of an hour, it was definitely worth it. The food was simply fantastic and the service was excellent. Admittedly, the prices were on the higher side, but considering the quality of the food and the fact that there are no cheaper options in the vicinity, it was understandable. Overall, it was a lovely experience and I would highly recommend it.