Rustler's Bbq - Henryetta

Overall impressions: There is ample parking available, and I didn’t experience any wait time. The restaurant is clean, well-lit, and has a modern yet rustic decor. As for the food: I ordered the brisket, which had a nice smoke ring, was moist, and boasted a pleasant smoky flavor. The pulled pork was a bit dry (though that could be a regional difference, as I’m from the Southeast), but it also had a good smoky taste. The fries were outstanding—crispy on the outside and soft on the inside, shaped like potato chips, making them perfect for dipping. The pickle fries were quite tasty as well; they were spears rather than chips, with a crispy batter coating a deli pickle. If I could deduct half a star for the religious decor on the walls, I would. Unfortunately, I can’t, so I’ll give this place a full five stars.

Absolutely delicious! The atmosphere is charming, and the food is fantastic. I highly recommend this place, especially for meat lovers. I ordered the Moabb, and it was incredible. My boyfriend, who has a bit of a sensitive stomach, found the hotlinks a little challenging, but everything else was excellent. If you're prone to stomach issues from certain meats like bologna or hot dogs, keep that in mind. Their BBQ sauce is also tasty. Overall, it was an amazing experience and a true highlight of the town!

This place is fantastic! We stumbled upon it while passing through and decided to check it out. The food is excellent! We tried the spicy pork tacos with potato dipper fries, the BBQ melt with Doritos, and the chopped brisket sandwich with Lay's chips. It was definitely worth the detour off I-40. We enjoyed everything so much that I forgot to take any pictures before we devoured it!

The Turkey breast was very tender. I also enjoyed their hot BBQ sauce. Rustler's has a bar! Rustler's also has a seven by amount of parking.

This place is our go to place anytime we are in the area. We stopped there coming back from Hot Springs. It was Mother?s Day was still good. Next month we will be back for some bologna! It?s the absolute best! The place is so nice friendly staff. If anyone is ever in the area, it?s well worth the stop to eat. You won?t be disappointed.