Tonino's Pizzeria - Hamden

Amazing pizza. I always think about picking up a pie but then I remember that they don’t have a 18 inch pie. The difference between a 16 vs 18 inch is equivalent to an 8 inch pizza extra so it’s a big deal breaker. An 18 inch is a real large size and I think they should offer it even if they label it as “extra large”. If they did this I’m sure more people including myself would order more. Their next size up is a party size which is way too big. For 2-3 people, a 16 is too small and it’s way too costly to order a 16 inch and a 10 inch. For the meantime, I will stick to their slices. Amazing pizza. Very NY style pie.

Decent pizza, crust seems to have changed. Not a fan

Customer service is over the top. Owner took the time to explain why reheating raw mushrooms for one slice of pizza wasn?t safe. He took the time to show me how he makes eggplant pizza which I never heard of. He brought the cooked eggplant from the kitchen to show me how they make it. The smell of his homemade Italian bread is amazing. Don?t miss this place on your travels.

My family and I order from this restaurant regularly. Every employee I have had the pleasure of dealing with, every delivery driver who?s dropped off an order- all have been extremely nice and considerate. Every single item on the menu is absolutely delicious, if you tell them you want your item done a certain way they will remember the next time you request it! It?s the little things that make toninos unlike any other restaurant in Hamden. I feel that if no other restaurant existed I wouldn?t care as long as toninos still delivered orders. Show love to these people they care about hospitality in a way that is unique to them it?s an amazing experience. I recommend the steak and cheese it?s the f?n best!

Years ago when I worked at Quinnipiac Polling, Tonino 's was my go-to for dinner . The pizza was always good. As I 'm no longer nearby, my visits are far and few between. Yesterday knowing I would be in the vicinity I looked forward to ordering a pie, only to be disappointed in not one but many aspects of my order. There was absolutely no crust. It looked like a cookie with sauce on top. The extra toppings were so scarce as to be almost non-existent as well as the sauce. The overall taste was so bland, I had to add some salt which as far as pizza goes, never, ever have I needed to add it to any pizza from my past. Needless to say I was extremely disappointed as pizza restaurants are a rarity where I now live. I was hoping for a knock out slice but instead got another failed attempt at serving good food. PS. The pie did not resemble the one on their website!