Coffaros' Pizza - Grove City

When you ask for extra sauce and cheese you get lite cheese and sauce slopped on top of the cheese

Awesome and friendly as you can get. The calzones are huge, great sauce and fresh as it gets. The dough is fresh and easy to tell its a hometown diamond in the rough. Definitely will be a steady customer moving forward. Also they sell by the slice...perfect for a fast bite!!!

Pizza not worth 1 star. Picked up a pizza on my way home Friday night, when I ordered it I was told 30-35 minutes before it would be ready. In 25 minutes I picked up a COLD, OVERDONE pizza. Crust was harder than the box it came in, when I asked how early I should have been there to avoid it being placed on top of the oven, I was told just depended on how busy they were, no time frame was given. If this was 1st time I would make an exception but it has happened at least 3 times, needless to say we will go elsewhere for our pie.

I had to reach out and give a little bit of credit because this is some of the best pizza and sides we have had in such a long time from anywhere local. We had a couple orders of their hot wings which were cooked perfectly, and the seasoning was very good, as well as an order of their jalapeño poppers and fried mushrooms, which were again fantastic and we had a few pizzas, chicken bacon ranch, a meat, lovers and a deluxe and I don’t give reviews very often but I will tell you this everything was delicious. Come to find out they are locally owned as well. Give them a shot, you will not be disappointed. We appreciate your dedication to good food and your delivery service is on point

Friendly service. Awesomely delicious pizza. Had never eaten Coffaro's pizza. Lots of veggies, delicious crust. Only one table 3 chairs, but we enjoyed their customers coming in for take out. Great pizza! We'll order it delivered or pick it up. Great pizza! Thanks!!