First And South - GREENPORT

Safe for those with food allergies and an all-around good time. Everyone is super friendly, too. Super close to main street for easy shopping or a pretty stroll after a good meal.

Nice place off the Main Street in Greenport. Located where it says... 1st and South. Nice menu, efficient service, good food and cocktails.

New to the area and currently focused on trying a new restaurant every weekend. I was excited to try First and South and enjoy a more American traditional restaurant. The atmosphere was great as it was packed and people were having a good time. The food was seriously ~okay~ my tuna burger was not medium rare which is what I asked for, it was well done. What I think the restaurant could most improve on is their cocktail program. For $16 I don’t think a cocktail should ever come with a clear plastic straw, poor quality ice, and no presentation other then a quarter of a lemon in a town where more and more cocktail bars are opening up with similar prices and exorbitantly better quality, First and South should take this to heart. Probably won’t return but glad I visited

We enjoyed our late lunch there. We enjoyed the fresh oysters and vinegrette they came with. Fries were cooked to perfection. The mussels were though overcooked. The brooth tasted delicious with fresh herbs and baby tomatoes. Some bread would have been good to sponge the remaining brooth. Burger was good, too.

Absolutely incredible meal! We came in at 3 (which is close) and they STILL seated and served us with a smile. The chowder was homemade and impeccable. The Oyster Po?Boy was phenomenal. The steamed mussels were divine. The **** Mary and Bellini were delicious and strong. The Oatmeal Pie dessert was SPECTACULAR!!! Each worker we interacted with was kind, friendly, polite, and engaging. Overall First and South has been hospitable, delicious, and pleasant. I would recommend this to anyone coming in from out of town. They are a hidden gem!!