Blue Sheep Bake Shop - Green Brook

Had made a top favor cake for my son's first birthday party. Not only the cake looked fantastic, it tasted just as good! Amazing! The Macaroons are supposed to die. The best place ever!

If I can give 10 STARS I TOTALLY WOULD!!!! Found an image of an amazing cake for my daughter's Sweet 16 and was a little unsure if they would be able to pull it off but wow was I wrong! Taste, texture, and the outside of the cake was SPOT ON!!!! EVERYONE WAS SOOO AMAZED EVEN MY DAUGHTER SHED A TEAR OVER HOW BEAUTIFUL IT WAS. I have been going to Blue Sheep for quite some time now and they never disappoint. A little pricey but you pay for convenience. Communication was also fabulous. They had contacted me over my daughter's vacay just to ensure the cake would be perfect to our liking. They definitely DELIVERED!!!! Thanks again to the baker's at Blue Sheep until next time!!!

Amazing cake, amazing flavor and design. Definitely worth the price, you and the team our outstanding. The white vanilla cake was outstanding and the strawberry swiss buttercream filling was on point. Thank You

We got our wedding cake from Blue Sheep Bake Shop and not only were they great to work with to get our design spot on, but the cake tasted incredible. We received so many compliments that it was the best wedding cake many of our guest have had. We got funfetti with a Nutella filling and it was amazing! Thank you Blue Sheep Bake Shop!

The wedding cake we had was absolutely stunning and delicious—truly the best I've ever tasted. Even a week after the reception, guests are still raving about it! The cake was vanilla, with a smooth buttercream exterior and delightful guava cream filling. It was the perfect balance, not overly sweet or heavy. We are already excited to order our baby shower cake from here. This place has definitely earned our lifelong loyalty!