Nicholas Creamery - Fair Haven

The ice cream from here is fantastic. I love the seasonal ice cream and out of the box flavors. I am giving you only three stars because your employees are very uncomfortable. I was faced with uncertainty and judgment. I was treated like a spectacle. If you are willing to go to an ice cream place where their employees judge you for getting ice cream from a job they work at then this place is for you.

It’s safe to say that Nicholas Creamery sells the best ice cream in Monmouth County. The flavors are always fresh, the service is always efficient, and the owners are outstanding. I also went to school with Mr. Harary’s son and can say that they’re an amazing family. Super kind, skilled, and welcoming

The ice cream sandwich here is outrageous in multiple dimensions: both it's deliciousness and it's cost. Is it worth it? That depends on you, but it's objectively delicious.

My friends were telling me about this place so obviously after eating at the restaurant I had to get the ice cream. The ice cream is exceptional but one thing to point out that I didn't know CASH ONLY. They have an ATM there but if you don't want to get charged then make sure to bring cash.

Ordered 2 different flavors… by no means were they creamy..both very icy..for $5 for a small cup I would expect above par quality