Teresa's Italian Deli - Erie

I found this addition to my sandwich quite surprising. It was rather unappetizing to have to pull something out of my mouth while I was chewing. It was really gross. I ordered a chicken tender sub, and there was absolutely no reason for this to be included. Perhaps it was meant to separate the deli meat, but it was added after the chicken was fried. Not great.

I needed catering for 50 people for a family funeral, and Teresa’s exceeded my expectations in terms of organization and professionalism! A big shoutout to the manager! The food was excellent and reasonably priced!

Additionally, I ordered rigatoni that came with just a small drizzle of sauce. The noodles at the bottom were completely dry and stuck together, so I had to buy three jars of sauce to mix in. Overall, I felt quite let down, especially after spending $124 on the food. It felt like I really got ripped off, and sadly, I won’t be returning. I understand that prices have gone up, but the quality was really lacking this time. I rarely write negative reviews, but I felt the need to express my disappointment after all these years of support.

Fantastic Italian hoagie and meatball sub. Great staff and outstandingly reasonable prices.

We went to Teresa’s for lunch today, we ordered a large chicken tender sub and pepperoni balls. The pepperoni balls are the only reason I gave it 2 stars. If it weren’t for them it would have been no stars. The chicken tender sub was basically a lettuce and bread sub. There was hardly any chicken on it (only had 4 tiny pieces on it and they were fatty pieces) and 2 slices of tomato. Normally the food here is great. Very disappointed.