Casey's - Erie

Went in today to get a 12 in sub and the cook told the cashier no she wouldn't make me a sub. I won't be going back to Casey's in Erie ever again. Not impressed at all with customer service

Today I ordered a small Supreme and some bread sticks. Thelma was working and it was some quick and on time. The pizza was one of the best I've ever had from there and we were very happy with our order. Great job Thelma

Amazing friendly staff and diligent working, always enjoy stopping at this Casey's.

Why is this Erie location so bad? Hour wait for pizza? Ok. Go to pick up pizza... they weren't even started. NEVER have we gotten our pizza order right. Sausage and mushroom pizza... forgot the mushrooms. Taco pizza NEVER the same. Last night no tomatoes or cheddar cheese. We have gotten it with no chips. Etc. We vowed NEVER to get pizza from this store again but my son was in town and really wanted it. Casey's in Erie another FAIL! Service: Take out

A couple of weeks ago I took advantage of the 7.99 single topping pizza deal. It was just OK for 7.99, but I would have been unhappy if I had paid full price. I don’t think they make them the same in promo deals. Very little cheese and the crust wasn’t even slightly brown. Now, I am afraid to buy one at regular price to verify! Great promotion Casey’s!