Buttermilk Sky Pie Shop - Colleyville

Buttermilk Sky Colleyville, Tx. is my go to for pies!! Their crust is the best I’ve had since my Grandmother’s,!! My favorite is chocolate cream, with whipped meringue, in a pie crust!! It’s a special order, so I call the night before, and it’s ready in the morning. I give pies as gifts, whom they all love! They have single, and regular size pies!!! The Woman owned business, and staff are amazing!!!

Good pie. Pecan is the best. I love apple but too sweet...too much topping versus apple so that apple is the main character in its own pie. ? If you can catch the seasonal strawberry pie....DO IT!!

I ordered the coconut cream pie and I couldn't even finish it. Too sweet for me. I was disappointed being I had been craving it and finally got it to not even enjoy it.

The owners here are great but the pies are not. We tried three varieties. The coconut taste was ok but not the best. The chocolate was just basically pudding in a tin covered by whip cream. I could make the same with in my kitchen with a box of jello pudding mix. And the peanut butter was just ok but not something to go back for. Def not worth the prices but so glad I bought the minis and not the fullPies!!! You'll do better heading to the grocery and buying Marie Callender!! A fun little trip to celebrate Pii Day but not for us as repeat customers. But again, the owners were super nice and run a good franchise. It's just the product that left more to be desired. I wish them the best of luck!

The pies are amazing. Be sure to buy a couple because you can't eat just one. They have a rewards program and the staff is amazing.