Milk Cookies Bakery - City of New York

THE best treat I've had in a long time. I went with salted caramel cookie with marshmallow caramel gelato, rolled in caramel bits

I had an expired Groupon from 2013, and this past Sunday, I happened to walk by this place. I remembered the unused Groupon and showed it to the cashier—no problem at all! The cookies were absolutely delicious! It's a really charming little cafe tucked away off the beaten path. The customer service was great, the prices were reasonable, and the atmosphere was comfortable. I give it two very enthusiastic thumbs up!

Milk and Cookies is the best place. My family always stops here on our way home from a trip to the city since we live in NJ. Always fresh. Always delicious. And always so friendly there!

I'm visiting New Jersey from California and we saw this shop on the insider so we made the drive over to the city just for Milk and Cookies. There was a young lady and young man working who were amazing! The young lady was so charismatic and very welcoming! She was interacting with us as if we had known her for years. Of course the gentleman was working hard to make the ice cream sandwiches. Thank you for not only providing amazing dessert but also for amazing service and hospitality! I can't wait to come back and send my traveling friends here!

I visited this place during a Foods of NY tour, and I can confidently say they have the best chocolate chip cookies I've ever tasted! The shop is adorable, and the staff were so wonderful. I will definitely come back!