Cape May Fish Market

I was pleasantly surprised by how DELICIOUS this meal was. When the plate first arrived, I was sad that I was being given a bag of chips as the side... I wonder if I could have substituted for actual fries. But, the fish soft taco wrap was truly so delicious. It was so juicy, packed to the brim with a generous portion of grilled shredded fish along with lettuce, onions, tomato, and cheese. The chipotle mayo tied everything together. Also came with a side of corn and black bean salad which was refreshing. The buffalo chicken wings were just average. Not amazing, with a bit of a spicy kick. A bit dry inside. This was the server's first time serving a table of 10, but he was so efficient and our food came so quickly! The vibes were cute inside, very cute.

Came here for dinner the other night and it didn't disappoint. The menu had a nice amount of things to choose from. I had the lobster roll which came with coleslaw and fries and my husband had the crab cake grilled cheese. The lobster was fresh and wasn't chewy. One of the best lobster rolls I ever had. My husband also enjoyed his meal. The waiter explained their crab cakes are homemade with little fillers. Would definitely love to come back!

Cape May Fish Market served the worst lobster rolls I've ever had, featuring small, stale pieces of mostly lobster claw meat. I was let down by New Jersey Monthly's recommendation of this place as a must-visit for lobster rolls on the Jersey Shore. As a fish market, they surprisingly offered no fresh fish at all. To top it off, the manager was quite rude. If you're looking for a great beach with soft sand and a better amusement park than Coney Island, I recommend taking a quick drive to Wildwood, New Jersey instead.

I'm not from New Jersey, so maybe these prices are typical here, but I was really surprised to find the seafood here was just as affordable, if not cheaper, than what I'm used to in Ohio. (I mean, being landlocked explains that a bit...) But considering the quality! My partner and I had initially planned to share the blackened scallop roll and the seafood roll, but in the end, we each got our own. The blackened scallop roll was a bit too heavily seasoned for my taste, but my partner really enjoyed it. The seafood roll was fresh and vibrant. As for the coleslaw, I usually find it hit or miss, but theirs was fantastic—just the right amount of sweetness. We had a group of around 10 people, and I was really impressed with how quickly the service was. They combined two tables for us without any hassle, which we appreciated. Although the wait to get in was a bit long, once we were seated, the service was prompt.

This restaurant offers a delicious Lobster Roll, which was a major factor in our decision to visit, and it definitely lived up to our expectations. The seating is a bit cramped, especially during busy times, but I appreciated how they were willing to rearrange our seats if we weren't in the best spot.