Mama Mia Pie And Pasta - Buckhannon

A family member recently moved to the area, so we decided to try this restaurant for dinner. The service was friendly and quick, and every dish we ordered was delicious. The garlic rolls were a highlight for us. We will definitely be returning! Everything was well-seasoned, and the chicken was perfectly juicy. We also loved the furnishings and the overall atmosphere of the place.

This place is a hidden gem! The food is exactly what you expect from a fine Italian restaurant, but with a cozy, inviting atmosphere. The staff is friendly and provides prompt service, but the standout for me was the garlic bread. It’s incredibly soft and fresh, made daily. As someone who travels frequently for work, I can confidently say that this is one of the best Italian restaurants I've ever experienced.

This is perhaps the best Italian restaurant I've ever been! I was everywhere in other countries. This little place was found in a small town in West Virginia called Buckhannon. We had Caprese Salat, Chicken Tortellini Soup, freshly baked garlic rolls, Rigatoni Francesco Rigatoni with meat sauce. Portions were plentiful and other guests themselves needed exhaust containers. Everything was made with the freshest ingredients. My Italian and a big cook myself, it is very rare I find an Italian restaurant that meets, let alone exceed my expectations, but this place hit it from the ball park! Well the 2 hours drive for us, as with the motorcycle we were vacation in Webster Springs.

Besides a 45-minute wait for my order and the wrong salad that had blue cheese crumbs that are not my thing... my eggplant was decided to make the sauce excellently fresh.... the fresh garlic rolls omg so good. The service was excellent

Beautiful, cozy restaurant with pleasant staff. The eggplant, manicotti, and alfredo is amazing. The bread is a perfect match of softness with a crispy outer layer that melts in your mouth. The gluten free ravioli is no longer available but the gluten free pizza was a success in our group, too. This was our first visit and we were very pleased! I can't wait to try the limoncello, canoli and tiramisu for dessert... We may make a trip just for appetizers and desserts to share. They have a small staff, so expect to be there a little while, and remember you can't rush perfection! Highly recommend!