Palermo's Pizza - Buckeye

This is the best New York Pizza in Buckeye, AZ. Period. I cannot vouch for their other dishes. I just haven't had them. But their pizza is the best when fresh, hot, and same day. Or use the broiler, or air fryer to reheat. ENJOY!

Great New York-style pizza that feels almost like home. We've tried other places, but this one is the most authentic.

I decided to give this place another shot after my first experience wasn’t great. What a mistake that turned out to be! The calzone I had was the worst I’ve ever eaten. It was so salty that it felt like I was dumping a salt shaker into my mouth, and I usually love salt. The sauce tasted spoiled, and there was no ricotta cheese at all! I ended up throwing most of it away, and what I did eat is now making me feel sick. It was absolutely terrible. I definitely won’t be ordering from here again! I really wanted to like it, but unfortunately, that just wasn’t the case.

During our journey through Buckeye, we decided to stop at this restaurant. The food was delicious and served in generous portions, and the beer was perfectly chilled. My son particularly enjoyed the cannoli and even wished for more. The staff was friendly and accommodating, especially the young lady who helped us with our blue glasses; she was very kind and attentive.

Nothing has changed still less than satisfying service. Staff makes comments about your order, the overall pricing has increased, value has dropped walked in as a last minute order for a birthday party. Never again. Wings were undercooked pizza was just marginal