Cream Sugar Cafe - Bethel

Fantastic experience! The ice cream is absolutely delicious, and their sundaes and milkshakes are enormous. Although it’s a bit pricey, it was definitely worth the hour-long trip we made. The customer service was exceptional—very polite and friendly. I will certainly make the journey again!

Wow! The ice cream is absolutely fantastic! If you decide to order the freak sundae, make sure to bring a big group with you; it's enough to serve six people! The cookies, brownies, and cake are fresh and just as delicious as the ice cream. I do wish there were more bathrooms available, but overall, it was an amazing experience!

Best shakes ever! These shakes were insane and out of this world. I got the belly buster and as you can see, it lived up to its name as a freak shake. It was around $15-$20 I believe and needs about 3 hungry people to finish lol. Everything about it was great and might be the best shake in the country, better that black tap nyc. Small but great!

What an experience! Worth the trip and the wait. Both times I've been, I was lucky to find a parking spot right in front. We waited about 10 to 15 minutes to get our freak shakes and the high school staff was as friendly as can be expected.

Good ice cream, the wait was a little long about 30 or 35 minutes. Really, really fun to see the looks on other customers faces when the ice cream comes out.