Belchertown Pizza

The best pizza around! We travel from Palmer just to get it. Their sauce is exceptional, and the balance of toppings is perfect.

This is the best pizza place in the area! The pizza is consistently cooked to perfection, and they use real mushrooms instead of canned ones.

I recently discovered this restaurant in the area, and I was blown away by the pizza! I ordered a large pizza with pepperoni, but it would have been just as delicious on its own. The sauce was fantastic, the crust was perfect, and the cheese tasted incredibly fresh. It really reminded me of the New York City pizzerias that I miss. I'm looking forward to exploring the rest of the menu. The staff behind the counter were really friendly, too!

If I could give zero stars, I definitely would. The only positive aspect was that the delivery was quick and the driver was friendly. Unfortunately, the pizza was absolutely terrible—honestly the worst I've ever tasted. I took one bite and ended up throwing the rest away. The sauce had an odd flavor, and the cheese tasted off.

The pizza here wasn't very good—it's quite similar to cafeteria-style pizza. Overall, I found it to be below average and overpriced. They charge different prices for cash and card payments, and there are additional charges for orders with meat. Honestly, the prices are too high for the quality of the food. I wish I could find the menu online, as it seems unavailable. I’d love to hear what I might be overlooking because I really want to enjoy this place.