Wise Guys - Appleton

This is the best deep-dish pizza I've ever had! Make sure to order in advance to skip the wait. The atmosphere is fantastic, and they always have great beer options available.

We visited this restaurant for the first time about a week ago, and it was refreshing to find a place where the servers genuinely pay attention to their customers. The stuffed crust pizza was fantastic and much larger than we anticipated. However, the mozzarella sticks were a bit disappointing; I wouldn't spend $10 on them again. We're definitely planning to return in a week or two because there are several other items on the menu that I've been wanting to try.

**Service:** While the staff seemed a little understaffed, they really went above and beyond to ensure we had everything we needed. Our server was incredibly friendly, contributing to a lovely evening out. **Food:** We initially came here in search of some delectable onion rings, drawn in by a mouthwatering photo on Yelp, but to our disappointment, they don’t actually offer them on the menu (insert sad face here). That minor hiccup aside, the menu is truly extensive, to the point we struggled to make our choices. My fiancé opted for the Donny burger, which features a sausage patty and beef patty topped with marinara and cheese, accompanied by fries. I decided on the Coco Calzone. We were both absolutely thrilled with our selections, and it will be a challenge to try something different on our next visit. Their French fries are irresistible—crisp and bursting with flavor from the seasoning they use. I can't wait to return, and I hope it's sooner rather than later!

Fantastic pizzas!! This place clearly stands out for the pizza that they serve. Our orders Calpone pizza Fried fish Spinach and Artichoke dip Sangria and beers. Capone pizza One with the Alfredo sauce and the other zesty.Both were immensely great especially the thin crust. Toppings well spread and delicious. The large serves 3 people and the small was good for 2. Excellent portions. The fish was served with baby potatoes and was a good addition to the menu. However, I have had better Friday fish fry. The surprise on the menu was the Spinach and Artichoke dip. Definitely a must have dish. It was mouth watering. The only Con was the waiting time. It was a busy night so we had to wait for 30 minutes. Great service, good food and how can i forget Sangria was epic too!

I love this Pizza. They lay it on like it should be. Their cheese is different than most. It tastes more high-end than the normal commercial mozz. It's buttery, heavy. The sauce is just right and plenty of it. Homemade crust starts it off. The oven looks like something special. The manager-owner-bossman takes pride in his pies. Have to say I love their big bag fries. Give them a try.1 more thing. Tastes great cold or nuked the next day.